The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria

I have now ordered here more than I can count in the last 6 months and every single time this place does not disappoint. My favourite pizza so far is the meat lovers and it is always cooked to perfection. The customer service is always exceptional. They really care about their customers and it shows every single time. Can’t wait to go back!

Fantastic pizza. I had a margarita slice. Friendly staff. I will definitely come back when I'm in the area. Also their name fourth man in the fire is very interesting if you're interested in learning about spiritually and philosophy. It's a reference to the Bible, I believe?

Tried the square cut pepperoni pizza for 28$.
This is about 10$ more than I am used to paying for a pizza that feeds 2 people but it was really great! If you are looking to try something different in Toronto, this dough is puffy and similar to garlic bread, with crispy fried cheese around the edges. The sauce tastes authentic not at all like a canned sauce joint. I will definitely be ordering from here again.

THIS. I choose to drive twenty minutes just to get pizza from this place. There are a whole bunch of places closer to home, but this is where I always want to come back to. I love it that much.

You can tell they take pride in their pizza. My favourite part, though, definitely has to be the crust. OH.MY.GOODNESS. I re-enter crust heaven with each bite. (I'm told they age the dough for 4 days to make it light and airy. Can anyone say, "Thank you?!")

May I mention the desserts they make in house?.... :) (drool.)

To top it all off, they have amazing people on staff. Sim is AWESOME! She makes me smile ear-to-ear each time I walk in.

The moment I entered this place I felt nostalgic as it seemed like a pizza joint that was passed on for generations. Loved the view of the cooks and the ‘walls of fame’! The pizza was spectacular: for me the sauce is key and I loved the chunky tomato texture of the sauce. This contrasted the thin crust very well which was light and crunchy at the rim. Loved the combo of jalapeños, thinly sliced pineapple, and pepperoni! Definitely give it a try! Will certainly be back!